Previous Next

Freedom versus Constraint

Of central significance to Angelou’s poem is the tension between freedom and constraint. This tension plays out on a structural level, as the speaker’s focus moves back and forth between the free bird and the caged bird. What results is a repeating pattern in which one stanza about the free bird is followed by two stanzas about the caged bird. Such a pattern establishes a motif of comparison in which the speaker juxtaposes the privileges of the free bird against the various forms of constraint suffered by the caged bird. Notably, this motif of comparison grants more attention to the caged bird, thereby demonstrating the speaker’s profound sympathy with his plight. Though the speaker describes the free bird in idealizing terms that underscore the joyful nature of his experiences, they don’t do so simply to extol the virtues of freedom. Instead, the speaker is keen to demonstrate how freedom is unequally distributed. When compared to the privileges enjoyed by the free bird, the brutality of the caged bird’s imprisonment becomes crystal clear. In this way, the poem’s central tension between freedom and constraint functions to underscore the profound injustice of the caged bird’s situation.

“But”

Key to the motif of comparison between the free bird and the caged bird is the speaker’s use of the preposition “but.” The speaker uses this word at two significant moments in the poem. The first instance appears at the beginning of the second stanza, as the speaker shifts their attention from the freedom of movement enjoyed by the free bird to the oppressive conditions that constrain the caged bird (lines 8–11):

But a bird that stalks
down his narrow cage
can seldom see through
his bars of rage

Here, the word “but” signals the change in the speaker’s focus. Given that the speaker lingers on the caged bird’s experience for two stanzas, this “but” also signals a realignment of their sympathies. That is, the speaker actively turns away from the ecstasy of the free bird and offers their attention to the caged bird’s plight. The speaker repeats this same rhetorical gesture later in the poem. Immediately following stanza 4, where they briefly return their focus to the free bird, the speaker shifts back to the caged bird (lines 27–28):

But a caged bird stands on the grave of dreams
his shadow shouts on a nightmare scream

Once again, the use of “but” signals a realignment of sympathies with the caged bird. In this way, the speaker implies that it’s more urgent for the reader to understand the oppression of the caged bird than the joy of the free bird.

Previous section Themes Next section Symbols

Take a Study Break